Wednesday, June 6, 2018

English 9--Notes for "The Lady, or the Tiger?"

The Gist of "The Lady, or the Tiger?"

  • punishment for crimes/reward for innocence = unknown "consequence" of a lady or a tiger
    • lady door = immediate wedding ceremony
  • the lady or the tiger system of justice was the king's idea
  • the king seems especially cruel for making his daughter's lover a pick a door
    • punishing his daughter, too!
  • the princess knows what is behind each door when her lover is in the arena, and she gives him a signal
  • no set answer exists for how the story ends--the ending is arguable based on reader analysis
Resonant Passages
  • "The semi-barbaric king had a daughter as blooming as his most florid fancies, and with a soul as fervent and imperious as his own."
  • "The girl was lovely, but she had dared to raise her eyes to the loved one of the princess; and, with all the intensity of the savage blood transmitted through long lines of whole barbaric ancestors, she hated the woman who blushed and trembled behind that silent door."
    • themes of love and hate explored
    • characterization of the princess--suggests that maybe she is more than only partially cruel
    • could be used as evidence in arguing the story's ending
  • bells are mentioned multiple times
    • bells of death
    • bells of happiness
    • the bells at story's end
  • "right" is repeated multiple times
    • a direction, but also suggests the word "correct" or the idea of "righteousness"
Characterization
  • the king
    • "semi-barbaric"
    • fully barbaric?!
  • the king's daughter (the princess)
    • like her dad
    • maybe more barbaric than her dad?
    • jealous of the lady behind the door
  • the lover of the princess
    • handsome
    • not royalty
    • understands the princess' personality
    • maybe trustworthy?
  • the lady
  • the tiger
  • a community member in the arena
Theme Words/Theme Statements
  • barbarism/savagery
  • choice
  • fairness
  • hate
  • human nature
  • influence
  • jealousy
    • One can make negative or positive or, even sometimes, life or death decisions based on jealousy.
  • justice
    • Who determines what is "just"?
      • In this case, it seems that the king and the king alone makes this decision in his creation of his justice system.
    • A form of justice that seems fair might not actually be fair when one actually thinks about it.
  • love
  • trust
Arguing About the Ending
  • The lady came out of the door at the end.
  • The tiger came out of the door at the end.